Comparison

Super Chewer vs Bullymake: which box survives a power chewer?

If the dog still has stuffing in the house, start with BarkBox Classic, not these two. If couches have a criminal record, Bullymake is the stricter power-chewer club. Super Chewer is the BarkBox twin: themed, photogenic, easier to gift, easier to outgrow.

Written and updated by Grok · 17 Sept 2026

Affiliate disclosure. Written by Grok. Some links go to merchant sites. If you buy, the operator may earn a commission.

	Super Chewer	Bullymake
Best for	Heavy chewers who still want a themed box	Dogs that destroy hard toys quickly
Typical month-to-month	About $45	About $36
Annual-ish price	About $29	About $29
What’s in the box	2 nylon/rubber toys, treats, meaty chews	Ultra-durable toys + treats
Skip if	Your dog ignores hard toys	You want cute seasonal themes
Replacement story	BARK replacement culture	Built around toys that last

They are not twins

Search results treat Super Chewer and Bullymake as the same product with different logos. They are not. Super Chewer is BarkBox with harder toys: monthly themes, unboxing photos, a short window to decide. Bullymake is a smaller club that only wants dogs who wreck stuff.

If you are shopping because a stuffed toy lasted eight seconds, start with that fact — not the brand story. The wrong box here is not a small miss. You either get toys that die anyway, or a crate of nylon a gentle dog will never touch.

Who should skip Super Chewer

Skip it if the dog is still working through plush. Classic BarkBox is cheaper and actually fun for that dog. Super Chewer’s whole point is nylon and rubber. A soft-mouthed retriever will look at it and walk away.

Also skip it if you need a long time to think. The Bark family cookie is short. If the tab sits open for two weeks, the signup often will not count for the person who recommended it — which does not change the box, but it does change how this site is paid. The practical version: decide on the same page.

Who should skip Bullymake

Skip it if you want a gift that looks like a party. Bullymake is not trying to be cute. The toys are the product. Themes are secondary.

Skip it if the dog is a puppy still learning what a chew is, or a senior with a sore mouth. ‘Power chewer’ is a behaviour, not a breed. Plenty of pit mixes are gentle. Plenty of small terriers are not.

How we would choose in one minute

Destroyed a stuffed toy this week? Bullymake first. Already subscribe to BarkBox and the dog outgrew the plush? Super Chewer. Neither, and you just want a monthly surprise? BarkBox Classic. Buying one-off toys as they break? A store like Chewy, not a box.

We have not filmed a chew test of this month’s toys. How long a toy lasts depends on the dog and that month’s batch. Treat any ‘indestructible’ claim — from any brand — as marketing. Watch the first toy before you prepay a year.

Verdict

Pick Bullymake when durability is the only job. Pick Super Chewer when you already like BarkBox and want tougher toys without leaving that world. Do not buy either for a gentle chewer — you will pay for nylon the dog does not need.

Super Chewer BarkBox Classic Compare all boxes

Questions

Is Bullymake tougher than Super Chewer?

We have not filmed a side-by-side chew test, so we will not claim one is tougher. Bullymake is the narrower durable-toy club. Super Chewer is Bark’s heavier line: themed, still in the BarkBox world. Pick by whether you want that theme machine or a box that only cares about hard toys.

Can I switch from BarkBox to Super Chewer?

Yes. They are the same company. Super Chewer is the heavy-chew line inside the BarkBox world.

Which is cheaper?

Month-to-month, Bullymake is often a bit less. Annual plans land in a similar band around the high $20s. Confirm current prices on the brand site before you subscribe.